Published on 5 November 2026
Last Updated on 5 November 2026
“You can lead a horse to water…”: why voting rights must match the paperwork
For shareholders planning an exit, the tax result can turn on details agreed years earlier. In Poznic, the First-tier Tribunal dismissed an appeal against HMRC’s refusal of Business Asset Disposal Relief (BADR) because the taxpayer could not establish that her B ordinary shares carried at least 5% of the company’s voting rights throughout the relevant period.
What happened?
Katarina Poznic had been a director and shareholder of StudioAnyo Architects Limited. The company allotted 100 ordinary shares to another shareholder and 100 B ordinary shares to Ms Poznic. When she later sold her B shares for £475,000, she claimed BADR on the resulting gain.
HMRC challenged the claim. The company’s Form SH01 and confirmation statements recorded that the other shareholder’s shares had voting rights while the B shares did not. HMRC’s closure notice increased the capital gains tax payable by £46,260.
Ms Poznic argued that the filings were wrong and that the share classes should rank equally under the company’s articles. However, the Tribunal found no written resolution, general-meeting minutes or other persuasive evidence showing that the B shares carried voting rights or that the statutory record had been corrected.
Why did Ms Poznic’s appeal fail?
For BADR, the company must be the individual’s “personal company”. Among the statutory conditions, at least 5% of the voting rights must be exercisable by the shareholder. The Tribunal treated the company’s statutory records and Companies House filings as prima facie evidence of the rights attached to the shares. Those records could potentially be rebutted, but doing so required cogent evidence. On the facts, that evidence was missing (not helped by the fact that neither of the relevant directors of the company attended the hearing).
In addition, the Tribunal noted that the company/appellant had in fact received specific legal advice that the records (both company and Companies House records) needed to be rectified but chose to ignore that advice.
RM2 comment
It’s all too easy to dismiss points like this as “mere paperwork” – but this is an excellent example of how incorrect filings can cost real money. Ideally, your Companies House records should be up to date and accurate at all times, and backed up by your own internal records. If filings or statutory books are inaccurate, correct them promptly and retain the evidence supporting the correct/true legal position. And definitely don’t leave them until a transaction happens!
As an aside, it is also worth noting that with an Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) option such an issue would not have arisen as there is no requirement with an EMI option to hold 5% of the company to qualify for BADR.
If you would like to speak to us about you employee share ownership arrangements, perhaps look through your plan documentation and give your employee share plan a health check we will be happy to have a call, just drop us a line at enquiries@rm2.co.uk